We all accept the value of the positive feedback - it increases the self-esteem of the other and may generate positive behaviors through the Pygmalion effect; social experiments in schools (Rosenthal study) have showed that expectations and positive feedback generate in the other one the desire to be “in the image and likeness of”, to confirm the hypothesis of the coach, of the professor, of the manager. Your expectations from the person standing in front of you come to life, are updated by him, as Pygmalion created a statue that came to life, because he believed in it.
But positive feedback can be bad. Here are two cases:
1. Unspecific, general - “good job, man”, “congratulations on how you treat others” - if you don't have arguments, it may sound fake, especially if the self-perception of the person about his/her performance is not good. And either way, the person is not aware of it, he/she doesn't know what to repeat next time in order to do it just as good.
2. Said for the sake of the emitter, not of the recipient - to offer positive feedback just for the others to like you, so you grow on them and, why not, on yourself.
And a few useful criteria-questions:
1. What will the recipient learn from this? Is it specific enough for him/her in order to learn something?
If I only say “congratulations, you did a good job”, it is possible that the person attributes the good job to whatever he wants. Adrian Stanciu gave such an example of defensive attribution during a conference, I will tell it as I remember it: let’s say you succeeded to cross a canal with your boat and during the crossing, because there was a good wind and you had nothing to do, you drank and got drunk. Adrian was saying that at the end, you may think, when giving yourself a feedback about your performance, something like: aha, I managed to do it because I was drunk (not in spite of!). I think it would be the same if somebody would tell you: congrats, amazing crossing. You may get to the same conclusion: I managed to do so because I was drunk. How helpful my “positive feedback” was!
2. Why do I give this feedback, what is the internal engine that generates this gesture? Who benefits more of it, I do or the recipient?
If it is only the pumping of my own ego and statute - I think twice. Most of the times, it's a mix - it helps me as well to see myself or others to see me as a generous person and I am also helping the other. It would, however, be good if the balance of the motivation would tip towards the other.
In order to help it tip a bit, I can, for example, change my transmission channel and method - I will not send an e-mail, I will tell it personally (it helps him even more to look him in the eye while I say it, even though, it would be more helpful for me to write it in an e-mail - it is faster, the other see as well that I am nice). Or, on the contrary, I won’t tell it when it’s just the two of us, but I’ll do it in public, during a meeting, if I know that he as well needs the respect of others.
Ștefania Antone
este Managing Partner, Top 20 traineri in Romania in 2019, trainer si consultant cu 17 ani de experienta in crearea si implementarea unor programe de dezvoltarea oamenilor, in mai mult de 50 de organizatii din Romania, Republica Moldova, Bulgaria, Turcia, Ungaria si tarile nordice.
Savannah AI
12 Apr 2024
Learning F(l)air 2024
18 Mar 2024
LEARNING F(L)AIR
05 Jul 2023
De vorba cu Anca Avram despre empowerment
16 Mar 2023
Mentoring for Better Trainers
06 Feb 2023
S.A.V.I.R.O.A.D – Jocurile Leader-Coach - Editia Bucuresti 14 septembrie
02 Aug 2022
S.A.V.I.R.O.A.D – Jocurile Leader-Coach - Editia Cluj 29 septembrie
01 Aug 2022
Super-lansarea workshopului game-based “S.A.V.I.R.O.A.D. – Jocurile Leader-Coach”
27 Jun 2022
Savannah – jocurile inteligentei emotionale
24 May 2022
Leading hybrid
24 May 2022
Rezultatele Training Insights 2022
18 May 2022
Training Insights 2022
18 Apr 2022
Noul nostru catalog e gata!
11 Apr 2022
Psychological Safety Learning Day – creste nivelul de siguranta psihologica in echipa ta!
16 Feb 2022
Virtual Meetings – transforma intalnirile virtuale intr-un spatiu al conectarii si prezentei!
16 Feb 2022
Houston League 2022
02 Feb 2022
Bestsellerele 2021
10 Jan 2022
Houston League
19 Nov 2021
6 Teams Conditions – eveniment de lansare – 18 noiembrie
25 Oct 2021
Leading Hybrid Teams – 28 septembrie
30 Aug 2021
Team Creator with 6TC
25 Jun 2021
Learning Holiday - cursuri open
09 Jun 2021
Leading Remote - Eveniment de lansare
15 Apr 2021
The Wellbeing Way - Eveniment de lansare
18 Feb 2021
Sesiune live open Trainerul Virtual
04 Feb 2021
Start cu sens
26 Jan 2021
Episodul 5 al podcastului Learn to Dare
13 Jan 2021
Episodul 4 al podcastului Learn to Dare
15 Dec 2020
ROMANIA cu mintea deschisa
24 Nov 2020
L&D Booster
17 Nov 2020
Neurowisdom - stiinta creierului pentru eficienta si echilibru
27 Oct 2020
Podcastul LEARN TO DARE Episodul 3
13 Oct 2020
Inscrie-te la evenimentul de lansare "The OmniLearning Experience"
11 Sep 2020
Podcastul LEARN TO DARE Episodul 2
07 Sep 2020
Podcastul LEARN TO DARE
26 Aug 2020
Webinarul Manage Uncertainty - cum sa iti creezi claritate in ceata
21 Jul 2020
Raport agregat - Open Your Eyes - Needs Assessment
17 Jun 2020
Get a taste of Business applied improv for Presence & Connection on Zoom
10 Jun 2020
Viata e o improvizatie frumoasa. Tu cu cine faci echipa in joaca asta?
09 Jun 2020
Open Your Eyes - Needs Assessment
21 May 2020
2 luni cat o viata
04 May 2020
Neurowisdom - stiinta creierului pentru eficienta si echilibru - 20 mai 2020
15 Apr 2020
THE MINDSET ACCELERATOR SERIES
20 Apr 2020
Pastila video impotriva anxietatii
15 Apr 2020
Mesajul Learning Architect de Ziua Mondiala a Sanatatii
15 Apr 2020
Peste 300 de oameni au invatat online cu noi in ultima luna. Iata parerea lor
01 Apr 2020
STAY CONNECTED. STAY ENGAGED.
25 Mar 2020
Webinar "Gestionarea nevoilor oamenilor in momente de criza"
18 Mar 2020
Ne vedem online - Virtual Soft Skills
17 Mar 2020
Webinar "Emotiile in momente de criza - cum comunici sanatos"
10 Mar 2020
Get a Taste of Skill Growth Hack - 31 ianuarie 2020
04 Dec 2019
Brain-based Coaching & Communication Skills Certificate
27 Nov 2019
L&D Bronze Award Company 2019
12 Nov 2019
Open House
11 Oct 2019